If I had a dollar for every time someone asked me this in the last two months, I would not need Plug and Post members, I’d just be retired. So let’s settle it.
Do you have to “yap” on camera to grow your account right now? Do you have to do talking head reels and only talking head reels?
My honest answer… no. But it’s a little more nuanced than a flat no, so let’s get into it.
Talking Head Reels Are Genuinely Great. Here’s the Catch.
I am a big fan of talking head reels. They build trust faster than almost anything else you can post. Someone watches one video of you and suddenly feels like they know you.
But here’s what people don’t show you. A good talking head reel takes scripting so you’re not rambling for ten minutes straight. It takes practice so you’re not stumbling over your words. If you use a teleprompter (I love them), it takes work to not sound like you’re reading off one. It takes editing to cut the dead space and the “ums.” And it takes something a lot of us don’t have naturally: speaking with conviction on camera.
Some people can just hit record and it works. I think of a pediatrician I follow who gets on every single day, talks about whatever happened, and it performs great every time. She has a natural gift for storytelling. That is not most people, and that is okay.
It’s Normal to Feel Burnt Out By This
If the idea of “I have to be on camera talking now to grow” makes you want to throw your phone across the room, you are so not alone.
I recently had a client ask me to shift toward more teaching style content on camera. We did it, and pretty quickly she told me she was starting to feel burnt out. I never want that for her, or for you. Content is supposed to help your business, not become the thing you dread every day.
Right now talking head content feels like the only thing working because it’s what’s trending. But b-roll reels still bring in followers. Carousels still bring in followers. Single graphic posts still bring in followers. One format being trendy does not mean it’s the only format that builds a business. I tell my clients this constantly, whether it was the “switch everything to Reels” moment or the “switch everything to Carousels” moment. My answer is always the same. Don’t put all your eggs in one basket.
The Content Mix I Actually Use
Here are the three formats I recommend, plus one optional extra.
B-roll. Quick, easy, low effort to shoot and edit. This is your consistency format. It won’t build deep trust on its own, but it keeps you visible and it’s sustainable.
Talking head. Your trust builder. I recommend one a week. It takes practice, it takes scripting (or ramble for ten minutes, get it transcribed, and have AI help you trim it into something tight), and it takes energy to show up with conviction. It is not a “just hit record” format.
Carousels. Polished and value packed. They take time to write and space out well, but they let you slow down and make a clear point, and people can swipe back to reread instead of scrubbing through video.
Optional fourth: single graphic posts. I don’t personally post many of these, but they consistently perform well for my clients.
The mistake is picking one and forcing yourself to live there. Unless you’ve found your thing, the format that lights you up and clearly works for your audience, a well rounded mix is what protects you from burnout and keeps building trust at the same time.
How to Build Your Own Mix, Step by Step
Step 1. Look back at two weeks to a month of your content. Label every post: b-roll, talking head, or carousel.
Step 2. Notice the one you’re avoiding. For me lately, it’s been talking head, because I’ve been dealing with some health stuff with my kid and just haven’t had it in me to get on camera. Is your avoidance a time thing, an energy thing, or camera fear? That tells you exactly where your friction is.
Step 3. Build your week around a simple ratio instead of guessing day to day. My typical week is about three b-roll, one to two talking head, and one to two carousels. That’s it.
Step 4. Batch the hardest ones when you actually have bandwidth. I batch recorded a bunch of talking head reels ahead of time so I could still show up consistently even during the weeks I was at the hospital with my kid.
The Mindset Shift
Growing on Instagram isn’t about matching whatever format is trending this month. It’s about showing up with a mix you can actually sustain.
You do not need to force yourself into two minutes of talking head every single day to prove you’re serious about your business. A sustainable mix beats a burnt out one every time. That’s the entire point of building a system instead of chasing trends.
Recap
- You do not have to do talking head reels to grow
- Talking head builds trust fast, but it takes real practice, scripting, and energy
- B-roll keeps you consistent without burning you out
- Carousels let people slow down and reread your point
- The mix, not one format, is what works until you’ve found your thing
- Build your week around a ratio, not daily guessing
Your Action Challenge
Plan three pieces of content this week using the same core idea: one as b-roll, one as talking head, one as a carousel. Notice which one took the longest, which one you actually liked doing, and which one you’d rather not repeat. Then watch how each one performs.
One More Thing
This is exactly why I built Plug and Post the way I did. You get content across all these formats every week, hooks, captions, and prompts already mapped out, plus an AI tool that pulls what your audience is actively searching for right now so your content stays specific to your niche. If you’re ready to stop guessing which format to force yourself into, come check it out.
Resources:
The Plug & Post Instagram Content Membership: Instagram content ideas, picked by me (an IG strategist) every week based on what’s working RIGHT NOW… so all you have to do is film and press post! – Join here!
100 IG stories that sell – $17
Say Hi on instagram! @nicoleialeggio
Try Manychat- 1 month free offer HERE
